This turkey mustard sandwich is my go-to option to make a deli-style lunch really feel additional particular. I layer sliced turkey, Havarti, crisp greens, and pickles between sourdough with stone-ground mustard and a brilliant herby mayo.

There’s plenty of crunch in each chunk: cucumber, purple onion, sprouts, romaine, and deli pickles. The herby mayo, made with mint, dill, cilantro, lemon, and mayo, brings the creamy, recent distinction that makes this sandwich memorable.
Featured Substances
- Sourdough bread: Select a sturdy, freshly baked loaf that may help the beneficiant filling.
- Stone-ground mustard and herby mayo: These two condiments give every slice of bread a definite, tangy-creamy taste.
- Deli turkey and Havarti: Use good-quality sliced turkey and creamy Havarti for the savory base.
- Recent greens: Inexperienced tomato, purple onion, alfalfa sprouts, avocado, deli pickles, cucumber, and romaine add coloration and crunch.
Herby Mayo
This do-it-yourself unfold is what units my turkey mustard sandwich aside. Recent mint, dill, and cilantro hold the mayo brilliant, whereas lemon juice provides a bit elevate.
- Mayonnaise: Use your most well-liked mayo; the prevailing affiliate hyperlinks to Duke’s, Sir Kensington’s, and Primal Kitchen stay under.
- Recent herbs: Use mint, dill, and cilantro for the meant taste profile.
- Lemon juice and sea salt: These stability and season the unfold.
Mayonnaise: I exploit my most well-liked mayo; some favorites are Duke’s, Sir Kensington’s, and Primal Kitchen.




Simple Ingredient Swaps
- Turkey: Substitute one other deli meat, reminiscent of ham or salami, if wanted.
- Havarti: Swiss, white cheddar, or provolone are all good sliced-cheese alternate options.
- Inexperienced tomato: Use one other massive slicing tomato when inexperienced tomatoes are unavailable.
- Stone-ground mustard: Yellow mustard or Dijon will work, although stone-ground mustard gives the meant texture.


Selecting Sandwich Bread
I like to recommend freshly baked sourdough from an area bakery when potential. Its sturdy crust and chewy inside assist the bread maintain the creamy mayo and juicy greens with out falling aside; in any other case, select a mushy bread with sufficient physique to help all of the layers.
Storage and Make-Forward Ideas
For the perfect texture, hold the sandwich elements separate till simply earlier than serving. If it is advisable to prep forward, retailer the herby mayo in an hermetic container and slice the greens near meeting; this helps stop the bread from turning into soggy.


What to Serve with a Turkey Mustard Sandwich
I like a traditional sandwich-and-chips lunch with air fryer candy tater chips. For a recent facet, serve it with creamy coleslaw or candy potato fries.
FAQs
What goes nicely on a turkey sandwich?
Creamy Havarti, stone-ground mustard, a recent herb mayo, avocado, cucumber, purple onion, sprouts, lettuce, and deli pickles all pair nicely with turkey. This recipe makes use of every of these elements for a sandwich with creamy, tangy, and crunchy layers.
What’s the greatest bread for a turkey sandwich?
Recent sourdough is a superb alternative as a result of it has sufficient construction for a generously stuffed sandwich. A sturdy mushy sandwich bread additionally works nicely when sourdough isn’t accessible.
Can I make this turkey sandwich forward of time?
Sure, however hold the components separate till near serving for the perfect texture. Put together the herby mayo prematurely, then assemble the sandwich if you end up able to eat.
Can I exploit a distinct cheese?
Sure. Swiss, white cheddar, and provolone are good substitutes for Havarti. Select a sliced cheese that you simply take pleasure in with deli turkey and mustard.
Make the herby mayo: in a small bowl, stir collectively the mayonnaise, mint, dill, cilantro, lemon juice, and sea salt till the herbs are evenly distributed and the combination is easy. Set it apart whilst you put together the sandwich elements.
Lay out 8 slices of sourdough bread. Unfold the herby mayo over one slice for every sandwich and the stone-ground mustard over the matching prime slice, coating the bread evenly so each chunk has each condiments.
Construct every sandwich on the herby-mayo facet: layer 3 slices of turkey, inexperienced tomato, purple onion, about 1/4 cup sprouts, avocado, sliced deli pickle, cucumber, Havarti, and romaine. Shut with the mustard-covered bread, press gently to carry the tall layers collectively, and serve immediately for the perfect crunch.
Repeat with the remaining components to make 4 sandwiches. Minimize every sandwich in half, if desired, and serve instantly; protecting the elements separate till meeting helps the bread keep recent.
- Use freshly baked sourdough out of your favourite bakery when potential; in any other case use a mushy bread sturdy sufficient to carry the filling.
- Turkey may be substituted with one other deli meat.
- Havarti may be substituted with one other sliced deli cheese.
[adthrive-in-post-video-player video-id=”wyxdEL1u” upload-date=”2024-07-31T00:00:00.000Z” name=”Favorite Turkey Sandwich” description=”We’re big sammie fans over here on Fit Foodie Finds, and this is our go-to favorite turkey sandwich recipe. It’s packed full of veggies, sliced turkey and cheese, and a homemade herby mayo you’ll make again and again.”]
Energy: 637 kcal, Carbohydrates: 78 g, Protein: 23 g, Fats: 27 g, Fiber: 9 g, Sugar: 10 g
Vitamin data is mechanically calculated, so ought to solely be used as an approximation.

